Quick answer: Pop Yachts, now called Pop Sells, is a registered Florida boat brokerage based in Sarasota and founded in 2009. It charges no upfront fees. It takes a 10% commission, with a $2,750 minimum, only when your boat sells. Reviews are mixed: a 4.7 Trustpilot score, but 23 complaints on file with the BBB.
Are you thinking about selling or buying a boat? Are you looking for a broker to help you sell or buy your yacht at a fair price?
Pop Yachts says it has a reputation as a trustworthy company that represents every vessel it lists competently.
Pop Yachts will help you sell your boat. If you want to buy a boat, they can help with that too. Below, we look at what they charge, what customers say, and where problems tend to show up.
Key Points:
- Pop Yachts now operates as Pop Sells, LLC, a Sarasota, Florida company started in 2009.
- It charges no upfront fees and takes a 10% commission ($2,750 minimum) when your boat sells.
- Reviews are split: most are very positive, but a smaller group is very negative.
- According to clients, the listing site and product photos are good and contribute to the positive outcome.
Is Pop Yachts the Same as Pop Sells?
Yes. Pop Yachts, LLC changed its name to Pop Sells, LLC. Florida records show name changes filed in 2015 and 2017. The company is still based in Sarasota, Florida. Its website is now popsells.com.
If you search for “Pop Yachts reviews,” you will often find reviews filed under the Pop Sells name. Check both names when you research the company.
Who Owns Pop Yachts?
Scott McNally founded Pop Yachts, LLC in Sarasota County, Florida, in 2009. The Florida business record lists an incorporation date of July 6, 2009. The same record lists the managers of Pop Sells, LLC as Paid On Performance, LLC, Mike Adams and Scott Wild.
Pop Yachts – How Good Are They?
Pop Yachts says it uses a strong web-based lead management system, plus a set process for following up with buyers until a sale closes. In short, the company focuses on online lead generation. It finds buyers on the internet and works them toward a deal.
POP Yachts does not charge any upfront fees to its clients; instead, they are paid based on their performance.
POP Yachts says every boat it works with should be accurately represented. The company says it shows up to 100 photos of each vessel it represents and will honestly answer all of your questions.

How Much Does Pop Yachts Charge to Sell a Boat?
They get a 10% commission ($2,750 minimum) when you sell your boat. Per Pop Sells, the $2,750 minimum applies to smaller units. That means a cheap boat can cost you more than 10% in fees.
Here is how the minimum works in practice:
- A boat that sells for $50,000: 10% is $5,000. You pay $5,000.
- A boat that sells for $20,000: 10% is $2,000. The minimum applies, so you pay $2,750 (about 13.75%).
- The break-even point is $27,500. Above that, you pay a straight 10%.
Does Pop Yachts Charge Upfront Fees?
No. Pop Sells says it charges no upfront fees and is paid only on performance. You pay the commission when the boat sells. Still, read your listing agreement for any other costs before you sign.
Some older reviews say Pop Yachts takes no commission if you find a buyer on your own. We could not confirm this. Ask the company to put its policy on private buyers in writing.
How Does That Compare With a Typical Yacht Broker Commission?
A 10% commission is in line with what many yacht brokers charge, though rates vary by broker, boat size and region. The bigger difference is the $2,750 minimum. If your boat is worth less than $27,500, compare that fixed cost against a private sale or a local broker.
How Reliable are Pop Yachts?
Pop Yachts’ stated goal is to be the world’s largest, most dependable, most advanced, and well-respected yacht brokerage. That is a goal, not a verified ranking.
Pop Yachts says it is dedicated to providing outstanding customer service. In every scenario, they say they strive to under promise and over deliver.
The company also says it puts time and money into giving sellers strong marketing and giving buyers a good purchase experience.
Pop Yachts works through local representatives who take their own photos, videos, and inventories of the gear on board. Before you sign, confirm two things: that there is a representative in your area, and whether the company has a minimum boat value it will accept.
What Do Pop Yachts Reviews Say?
Reviews lean positive overall, but complaints are real and worth reading. Here is where the company stands on the two main review sites.
Trustpilot Rating
On Trustpilot, popsells.com has a TrustScore of 4.7 (“Excellent”) from 2,325 reviews.
| Star rating | Share of reviews |
|---|---|
| 5 stars | 84% |
| 4 stars | 6% |
| 3 stars | 2% |
| 2 stars | Under 1% |
| 1 star | 7% |
Note the shape of that data. Very few reviews sit in the middle. Customers tend to have a great experience or a bad one.
What Is Pop Yachts’ BBB Rating?
The Better Business Bureau lists Pop Sells, LLC in Sarasota, Florida, with 23 customer complaints and 200 customer reviews. Check the BBB page for the current letter grade and to read how the company answered each complaint.
What Are Typical Problems with Pop Yacht?
SCAM is a big word for any company. Unfortunately, there is no easy way to detect whether a company has crossed the line from poor product and service delivery to outright fraud.
POP Yachts has been the subject of numerous online complaints. Surprisingly, these evaluations are either very positive or very terrible, with only a few in the between, implying that POP Yachts customers have either very good or very bad experiences.
The most common complaint themes on Trustpilot are:
- Condition not matching the listing. Some buyers say the boat was not in the shape the listing described.
- Aggressive sales tactics. Some customers felt pushed during the process.
- Paperwork and communication delays. Some say titles, documents or replies took too long.
Is Pop Yachts Legit or a Scam?
Pop Yachts is a legitimate, registered business. It has operated since 2009, has a public BBB profile, and has thousands of reviews. That does not mean every deal goes well. The complaints point to service problems, so protect yourself the same way you would with any broker.
How dedicated is Pop Yacht?
Scott McNally founded Pop Yachts in Sarasota County, Florida, in 2009 with the goal of creating a dynamic boat brokerage. The goal was to become the world’s largest boat and yacht brokerage.
The company is a commission-based broker. It does not offer commission-free sales. It charges 10% of the sale price, with a $2,750 minimum for smaller units.
In its own words, Pop Yacht aims to accomplish its mission by:
- Being completely honest, accurate, and forthright in their actions and words so that our customers have a clear understanding of the experience.
- Providing a complete and accurate description of EVERY listing we represent so that our customers don’t lose time or money.
- Responding to customer requests and following up promptly so no one is waiting on them.
- Keeping their customers constantly informed throughout the entire process so the customers ALWAYS know what is happening.
- Providing the sellers with the best marketing opportunities at the most reasonable pricing.
- Constantly innovating and removing barriers, in this constantly changing world to better serve the requirements of our customers and employees.
- Rather than acting as a single broker, they work as a team to EXCEED our clients’ expectations.
- Recognizing when they could have done better, taking responsibility for our actions, and taking efforts to avoid making the same mistakes again.
Compare these promises with the complaint themes above. Communication and accurate listings are both on the list, and both show up in negative reviews.
What Should Buyers Know Before Buying Through Pop Yachts?
Since the top complaint is boats not matching their listings, buyers should verify everything themselves. Ask the broker these questions before you send money:
- Are there any buyer fees? Get the full cost in writing.
- Can I do a sea trial? Run the boat on the water before you commit.
- Can I hire my own marine surveyor? Choose an independent surveyor, not one picked by the seller.
- How is my deposit held? Ask who holds the funds, under what terms, and when a deposit is refundable.
- Is the title clear? Confirm there are no liens before closing.
What Should You Check in the Listing Agreement?
Your listing agreement controls what you owe and when you can leave. Read it fully before you sign. Look for:
- Contract length: How many months does the listing last?
- Exclusivity: Can you list the boat elsewhere or sell it yourself?
- Private buyer terms: Do you owe a commission if you find the buyer?
- Cancellation terms: How do you cancel, and is there a notice period or fee?
- Extra costs: Are there any marketing, photo or other fees?
Can I Cancel My Pop Yachts Listing Agreement?
It depends on the terms in your signed agreement. Before you sign, ask how to cancel, how much notice you must give, and whether any fees apply. Get the answers in writing. If you have already signed, reread the cancellation section and contact the company in writing.
How Can You Protect Yourself With Any Online Yacht Brokerage?
These steps apply to Pop Yachts and any other online broker:
- Check the company on the BBB, Trustpilot and your state’s business records.
- Read the negative reviews, not just the average score.
- Get every fee and term in writing.
- Never wire money to a personal account.
- As a buyer, insist on an independent survey and a sea trial.
- As a seller, review your listing for accuracy before it goes live.
- Keep copies of all emails, texts and documents.
Red flags: pressure to sign or pay fast, vague answers about fees, refusal to allow a survey, and contracts with no clear way out.
How Does Pop Yachts Build Its Track Record?
Pop yachts’ mission is to be the world’s largest, most dependable, most advanced, and well-respected yacht brokerage. We could not verify the company’s total sales count, so we do not quote one here.
The company’s model leans heavily on online marketing and technology to reach buyers. Its long run since 2009 and its large number of reviews show it is an active, established business.
What Are the Pros and Cons of Pop Yachts?
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| No upfront fees; paid only when the boat sells | $2,750 minimum commission hits small boats hard |
| Strong Trustpilot score (4.7 from 2,325 reviews) | 23 complaints on file with the BBB |
| Detailed listings with many photos | Some buyers report boats not matching listings |
| Operating since 2009 | Reports of aggressive sales tactics and paperwork delays |
Which Boat Brokerage Can be the Best Alternative to Pop Yachts?
The degree of competitiveness in this industry is not easy. A number of yacht brokerages are constantly battling to be the best. The existing elite teams are-
- Fraser
- IYC
- Moran Yacht & Ship
- RJC Yacht Sales
- Denison Yachting
Several of these firms are best known for large yachts. If you own a smaller boat, these options may fit better:
| Option | How it works | Best for | Fees |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pop Sells (Pop Yachts) | Online-focused broker with local reps | Sellers who want a broker to handle marketing and buyers | 10% of sale, $2,750 minimum, no upfront fees |
| Large yacht brokers (Fraser, IYC, Moran, etc.) | Full-service brokers | Large and high-value yachts | Ask each broker |
| Local boat broker | In-person broker in your area | Owners who want face-to-face help | Ask each broker |
| Boat Trader | Online listing site | Smaller boats and private sellers | Check current listing prices |
| YachtWorld | Online listings, mostly through brokers | Buyers browsing broker inventory | Set by the listing broker |
Who Should Use Pop Yachts?
Use this simple decision rule:
- Good fit: Your boat is worth well over $27,500, Pop Sells has a rep near you, and you want someone else to handle marketing and buyers.
- Poor fit: Your boat is worth less than $27,500, since the $2,750 minimum takes a bigger share. A private sale or listing site may cost less.
- Poor fit: You want in-person service with one dedicated broker. A local broker may suit you better.
Final Thoughts
Pop Yachts, now Pop Sells, aims to become the largest boat and yacht brokerage in the world. The company says excellent customer service is the key to its success, and that it wants to help raise customer service standards in the marine business.
Pop Yachts is a legitimate option if you want a broker to sell your boat with no upfront cost. Its Trustpilot score is strong, but the BBB complaints and mixed reviews mean you should read your contract closely, get every term in writing, and verify any boat before you buy.
Related Posts:
- Boats.net Detailed Review: Are they Good and Reliable?
- Anchor Express Review: Are They Good and Reliable?
- Shibumi Shades Review: Are They Good and Reliable?
- Online Outboards Review: Are They Good and Reliable?
- Hodges Marine Review: Are they Trustworthy and Good?
Frequently Asked Questions About Pop Yachts
Does Pop Yachts charge a commission if I find my own buyer?
This is not confirmed. Some older reviews say Pop Yachts takes no commission when the seller finds the buyer, but this could not be verified. Check the private buyer terms in your listing agreement. Ask the company to put its policy on private buyers in writing before you sign.
Where is Pop Yachts located?
Pop Yachts, now Pop Sells, LLC, is based in Sarasota, Florida. The company was founded in Sarasota County in 2009, and its website is now popsells.com. It works with sellers through local representatives. Confirm there is a representative in your area before you sign a listing agreement.
Who takes the photos for a Pop Yachts listing?
Local Pop Yachts representatives take their own photos and videos of each boat and record the gear on board. The company says it shows up to 100 photos of each vessel. Sellers should still review the listing for accuracy before it goes live, since some buyers report boats not matching listings.
How long has Pop Yachts been in business?
Pop Yachts has been in business since 2009. Florida records list an incorporation date of July 6, 2009, in Sarasota County. The company later changed its name to Pop Sells, LLC, with name changes filed in 2015 and 2017. It now has thousands of online reviews on Trustpilot and the BBB.
